teknolojiarsivi.com
teknolojiarsivi.com June 25, 2017


Supreme Court Strikes Blow Against Patent Trolls, Says CCIA

24 May 2017, 05:35 | Vickie Mathis

Supreme Court makes it much harder for patent trolls to sue in East Texas

Supreme Court puts new restriction on patent trolls

These lawsuits are complex and expensive, sometimes costing each side millions of dollars in attorneys fees alone.

While the ruling could effectively shake up the legal infrastructure around patent suits, it won't prevent those suits from happening. Not surprisingly, such lawsuits can dramatically alter the competitive landscape in any given industry and change business fortunes. "This ruling will help these businesses and their employees focus on innovating and creating, not on defending against abusive litigation tactics". The AGs "have an interest in protecting their citizens from abusive claims of patent infringement, which businesses and residents confirm are a drag on economic growth".

In 2015, a report from Unified Patents showed a surge in patent lawsuits was being driven by non-practicing entities (NPEs).

In fact, more than one-third of patent lawsuits are filed in the Eastern District Texas, a venue known for favorable rulings and massive jury verdicts. These variations can impact the substantive outcome of a patent lawsuit, because patent cases are closely supervised by judges (who, like anyone else, have their own biases) and also involve trials by jury. "Patentee-friendly jurisdictions - in particular, the Eastern District of Texas - are destined to see a dramatic decline in patent litigation".

"The half of patent cases previously filed in East Texas will now have to shift to places like Delaware, California and NY", patent attorney Shawn Hansen said Monday.

Following the conclusion of the case, which ruled for Kraft, TC Heartland took its appeal all the way to the Supreme Court. More than 40 percent of all patent cases have traditionally been filed in the Texas district, according to The New York Times-becoming a well-known example of "forum shopping" in legal circles. This is thought to be because of the high success rate these patent trolls have in the district, garnering wins that other areas would, perhaps, rule as losses.


The US Supreme Court ruled (PDF) today on how to interpret the patent venue laws, and the controversial business of "patent trolling" may never be the same.

Yesterday, the court concluded that the amendments to section 1391, the statute governing "venue generally", didn't modify the meaning of section 1400 (b), the patent venue statute. If alleged infringers only "reside" in their state of incorporation, as opposed to anywhere they are subject to personal jurisdiction, patent holders will no longer necessarily get to choose the venue in which they may file a patent infringement lawsuit.

The reputation of East Texas juries for handing down mind-boggling verdicts (one jury previous year ordered Apple to pay $625 million to a shell company over patents from 1998) led many companies to simply pay the trolls to go away even if the patents in question appeared to be of dubious quality.

"Given the definition of "resides" is limited to the "state of incorporation, ' it may lead to a swell in patent cases in DE, and otherwise funnel cases towards defendants" home jurisdictions", said Kirkland & Ellis intellectual property partner John O'Quinn.

This development represents good news for Idaho's rapidly growing economy. Heartland attempted to get the matter transferred to its home state of IN, arguing that it has no presence IN DE and that 98 percent of its sales come from outside of the state.



Other News

Trending Now

Ford using first over-the-air software updates to its 2016 cars
If any update becomes available then the SYNC system will download and install the update in the background. This marks the first time that Ford will enable one of its updates to be applied via WiFi.

Rebel Wilson sues magazine publisher over 'nasty' articles
He said Wilson thought "she'd never been hit with such nastiness" when Bauer Media published "grubby articles" that defamed her. Ms Wilson flashed her trademark smile and nearly looked the part in this new court drama. "I have no current job", she said.

Ducks Snap Predators' Home Playoff Winning Streak
They saw two goals waved off in eight seconds, shortly after Forsberg's equalizer at 3:55 of the third period made it 1-1. Subban scored off a blast from the blue line to revive the standing-room only crowd with Forsberg helping screen Gibson.

National Basketball Association mock draft 2017: Markelle Fultz, Lonzo Ball lead fresh faces
Worst case scenario, the pick drops to no. 4, where the player chosen could still turn out to be just as good as the guy at no. 1. Throwing in the 2018 Nets pick gives in a chance at the top player next year, which would most likely be Michael Porter Jr.

Nigerian troops battle Boko Haram in Lake Chad area, kill 13
Joyous scenes occurred in the capital, Abuja, Saturday when 82 newly freed Chibok schoolgirls were reunited with their families. A government list of names circulated, and parents were asked to confirm the freed girls' identities through photos.

NASCAR's Aric Almirola out 8-12 weeks with broken back
A week later, he was hospitalized overnight in Kansas before flying home to North Carolina to receive another diagnosis. Almirola fractured the T5 vertebra in the middle of his back in a crash in last Saturday's race at Kansas Speedway.

Dier doubts Tottenham's title hopes
Second half we started a little bit sloppy and we conceded a little bit more space. Tottenham suffered a damaging defeat at West Ham on Monday.

Victor, J.D. Martinez home runs lead Detroit Tigers over Baltimore Orioles
Danny Duffy picked up first victory since April 14, and Mike Moustakas belted a three-run homer as Kansas City defeated NY . He had thrown just 31 pitches, even with two walks, in the first two frames, but got in trouble early in the third.

Kylie Jenner : People have misconceptions about who I am
As far as the angsty transformations of puberty go, Kylie Jenner puts most of us pimple faced, greasy haired teenage mutants to shame.

Aishwarya Rai's first day at Cannes Film Festival 2017
Aishwarya arrived in Cannes on Friday morning with her daughter Aaradhya and spent the day getting ready for her first outing. Her best appearance so far has been her golden mermaid look in Roberto Cavalli golden off shoulder evening gown.